Top 15 Comic Book Movies
Posted on December 13, 2007
Filed Under Top 15 Lists |
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
I am a big fan of comic book movies and I assume a lot of you are as well. That’s probably a safe assumption because Hollywood has been churning out these moneymakers on a consistent basis since the first X-Men flick was released back in 2000. That trend will continue in 2008 with Iron Man, The Dark Knight and The Incredible Hulk all hitting the big screen next summer.
Some comic book movies are really good or great, others not so much (see Spider-Man 3, Hulk) and still others downright stink (see Ghost Rider, Blade: Trinity). Here are the 15 comic book movies I think fall into that first category. Each of these flicks was based on comic book characters and/or a graphic novel.
15. Daredevil (2003)
I am sure some (or a lot) of you will disagree with this choice, but this movie actually surprised me. I am not a big Ben Affleck fan, but he did a solid job as, as far as I know, the only blind superhero.
14. Sin City (2005)
What a visual treat this flick is (no, not just Jessica Alba). Great story, great performance by Mickey Rourke and, hopefully, a great sequel one day.
13. Superman Returns (2006)
There will always be only one Superman to me, but Brandon Routh does a solid job as the new Man of Steel. I really liked that this Superman flick was for more mature audiences. Here’s the teaser trailer, which I like more than the full trailer.
12. Blade II (2002)
Better than the original? It’s a close call, but I give a slight edge to the sequel. As I stated in a previous post - combining horror and action is usually fun.
11. X2: X-Men United (2003)
You wanted more action and Wolverine going nuts? Here you go - enjoy.
10. Superman II (1980)
Superman II gets high marks for a decent plot and villains that can match the Man of Steel’s strength. I still need to see the “Richard Donner Cut” of this flick.
9. A History of Violence (2005)
Yes, A History of Violence is based on a graphic novel. I love this flick and its portrayal of a man trying to leave his violent past behind. If you haven’t seen it, do so. You won’t be disappointed.
8. Batman Returns (1992)
Some consider Batman Returns superior to the original, but for me the original Batman edges this flick by a whisker (or flipper). Batman Returns takes the dark mood set in Batman and goes further. This movie is definitely not for the kitties, I mean kiddies. Sorry.
7. Batman (1989)
Back-to-back Batman. Jack Nicholson gives a classic performance as the Joker and Tim Burton creates a world that has both a futuristic and retro feel at the same time.
6. X-Men (2000)
The original and best. Not as much action as the sequel, but we really get to know the characters and their pain in this flick. Wolverine’s introduction to the audience is great - he is cage fighting in a bar. After that introduction, you just knew that Brian Singer was going to get this right.
5. The Crow (1994)
I won’t get into all the parallels between the character in The Crow and the tragic death of Brandon Lee. I will save that for this flick’s entry in my Top 100 Movies list. Rather, I’ll focus on the atmosphere created by director Alex Proyas, who has done some amazing work in his career thus far (e.g. Dark City). Proyas takes a gothic character and puts him in a dirty and seedy city that is overrun by crime and uses the music of the time to bring it all together.
4. Spider-Man (2002)
Spider-man was it for me as a kid. I couldn’t get enough of the comics, toys and cartoons. So when they (finally) announced they were making this flick, I was ecstatic. I do think they screwed up The Green Goblin’s look, but Willem Dafoe was great as Harry Osbourne.
3. Superman: The Movie (1978)
Christopher Reeve was and is Clark Kent/Superman and the original movie shows you why. Not as action-packed as Superman II, but a great origin story and introduction to the Man of Steel.
2. Spider-Man 2 (2004)
Spider-Man 2 is considered by many to be the best comic book movie of all time. I don’t (obviously), but it is superior to the original with a better villain and plot as well as more action than its predecessor.
1. Batman Begins (2005)
Has there been a more “realistic” portrayal of a superhero on film? No. Has there ever been a better back story for Bruce Wayne/Batman? No. That combined with two solid villains, great action, solid acting and fine direction by Christopher Nolan make Batman Begins the best comic book movie of all time. However, that may change after after The Dark Knight is released next summer.
Tags: a history of violence, alex proyas, batman, batman begins, batman returns, ben affleck, blade ii, blade III, brandon lee, brandon routh, brian singer, bruce wayne, christian bale, christopher nolan, christopher reeve, comic book movies, daredevil, fantastic four, ghost rider, graphic novel, green goblin, hulk, iron man, jack nicholson, jessica alba, list, michael keaton, mickey rourke, sin city, spider man, spider man 2, spider-man 3, superman, superman ii, superman returns, superman the movie, the crow, the dark knight, the incredible hulk, the joker, tim burton, top 15, wolverine, x-men, x2 xmen united
Comments
9 Responses to “Top 15 Comic Book Movies”
Leave a Reply
Top 15 Comic Book Movies : Flicks Lists…
I am a big fan of comic book movies and I assume a lot of you are as well. That’s probably a safe assumption because Hollywood has been churning out these moneymakers on a consistent basis since the first X-Men flick was released back in 2000. That t…
Fantastic list…I had no clue History of Violence was based off a graphic novel.
However, if you are going to go off that, isn’t 300 a graphic novel? I’d put that up there before Daredevil
Thanks Mike. Yeah, 300 was a graphic novel. I’ve seen it and enjoyed it. Great visuals. V for Vendetta was another one that I considered. However, I tend to favor superhero movies in this genre. Sin City, A History of Violence and The Crow were so good that I had to put them in this list.
Good list. I thought I might see Hellboy on there somewhere though
Great list. A couple I wouldn’t have had like, Superman Returns or Daredevil. Loved Sin City and agree that Batman Begins may be the best ever. Bring on The Dark Knight.
Thanks Scott! What would you replace Daredevil and Superman Returns with?
[…] Top 15 Comic Book Movies […]
[…] Steven (12) - Blog Highlight: “Top 15 Comic Book Movies.“ […]
Being the BIGGEST comic book nerd on the planet, thanks for compiling the list. Though the Capn certainly would have had Superman returns in the top 5 easy. The movie was slow for many , and alot didnt like it was more a Lois Lane love story than an actual Superman movie, but even the big man director himself said, this was a setting stage for the sequel to follow….stay tuned for a true action Superman movie.